• Banner 1
  • Banner 2
  • Banner 3

Best Choice Jamaican Jerk & Seafood – Authentic Jamaican Flavors in Yonkers, NY

Best Choice Jamaican Jerk & Seafood in Yonkers, NY, delivers authentic Jamaican flavors with standout dishes like hearty oxtails, flavorful curry goat, and comforting chicken soup. Their meals impress with generous portions and well-balanced spices, satisfying both spice lovers and those seeking milder options. Customers praise the friendly, attentive service and homemade island-style juices that complement the vibrant menu. While the space focuses on takeout, the food’s warmth and freshness shine through consistently. For anyone craving genuine Caribbean comfort food with a personal touch, Best Choice offers a reliable, flavorful experience that keeps patrons coming back.

Best Choice Jamaican Jerk & Seafood at a glance

  • Address 96 New Main St, Yonkers, NY 10701, United States
  • Phone +1 914-294-0770
  • Restaurant type Caribbean restaurant .
  • Popular for Lunch , Dinner , Solo dining .

Photos & Gallery

Best Choice Jamaican Jerk & Seafood: Reviews & Ratings

Imani VK
5

I’m not sure why everyone is complaining about the amount of food and price. This is what I got for $20 as a large, and it definitely filled me up and I still had leftovers! They are the only place I get my oxtails from, customer service is great, the ladies are always pleasant when I walk in to order or when I call in.

Delia Bey
4

Excellent chicken soup and reasonably priced. The homemade juices were an added treat. I would definitely recommend to those who want yummy food to go.

Likkle Shan
5

Was a bit shocked when I read other reviews. This is some really good Jamaican food and that’s coming from someone who was born and raised in Jamaica. The server was very polite and broke down the prices well. It was my first time going in there and I have to say, I will be going again. The food is cooked and spiced nicely. I do understand tho, that some people can’t handle spice. So maybe for stuff like curry chicken/curry goat, have a spicy and a non spicy option. Beside that, the food is good, clean place and nice customer service.

James Mifflin
4

All my food was hot except for my fish. Could have been warmer. Employees were nice and friendly.

Amir Saunders
5

I was able to order a large curry goat with rice and peas and cabbage. It did not take long before my food is ready. I also have the island vibes nectar. Tropical island punch was very good. This food here is amazing. The only thing that kind of sucks is that there’s not really a place to eat but if you want good food on the goal definitely check this place out.

Location

  • Best Choice Jamaican Jerk & Seafood
    Best Choice Jamaican Jerk & Seafood
    96 New Main St, Yonkers, NY 10701, United States Hotline: +1 914-294-0770

Best Choice Jamaican Jerk & Seafood, located at 96 New Main St in Yonkers, NY, stands out as a vibrant destination for authentic Jamaican flavors. This spot offers a true taste of the islands, specializing in hearty jerk dishes and fresh seafood that bring the rich heritage of Jamaican cuisine to life. From the moment you walk in or call ahead, the welcoming staff set the tone for a pleasant dining experience, as many patrons have noted the friendly and courteous service.

One of the highlights here is the generous portions that come at a fair price. For instance, their large plates, such as the renowned oxtails, curry goat, or jerk chicken served with classic sides like rice and peas or cabbage, consistently leave diners satisfied and often with leftovers to take home. The flavors are deeply rooted in tradition—spicy, smoky, and well-seasoned—though the kitchen thoughtfully considers varying heat preferences, which shows their attention to customer comfort.

The menu also features standout comfort dishes like their excellent chicken soup, which offers warmth and depth, perfectly complemented by homemade tropical juices that echo the vibrant island spirit. These homemade drinks, including the popular island vibes nectar, add a refreshing touch that balances the bold spices of the main courses.

While the place is primarily geared towards takeout, and seating options are limited, the food’s freshness and quality make it well worth the trip. Whether you are a longtime fan of Caribbean cuisine or a newcomer eager for an authentic experience, Best Choice Jamaican Jerk & Seafood delivers mouthwatering, soul-satisfying dishes with genuine island hospitality.

Business Information

  • Service options
    • Delivery
    • Takeaway
    • Dine-in
  • Payments
    • Credit cards
    • Debit cards
    • NFC mobile payments
    • Credit cards